Main
Search This Site

« back to New and Improved!
» forward to We've Moved!

Discussion Archives
Bel Canto
blindness
A Box of Matches
Bridge of Birds

a canticle for leibowitz
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Chronicle of a Death Foretold
A Confederacy of Dunces
confessions of an ugly stepsister
Coraline
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time

descent into hell
The Dew Breaker
The Diamond Age
Doctor Zhivago
don quixote

Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close

Fight Club
The Five People You Meet in Heaven
Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe

The Ghost Writer
good in bed

harry potter and the sorcerer's stone
A Home at the End of the World
House of Leaves

If on a Winter's Night a Traveler
invisible monsters

The Kite Runner

Life of Pi

memoirs of a geisha
Middlesex
Motherless Brooklyn
mysterious skin

Neverwhere
noir
Norwegian Wood

One for the Money

the poisonwood bible

revenge
Running with Scissors

The Secret Life of Bees
shopgirl
The Solitaire Mystery
The Stupidest Angel

Things Fall Apart
Thumbsucker
The Time Traveler's Wife
Troll

Veronika Decides to Die

The Wasp Factory
Watch Your Mouth
What is the What
A Wrinkle in Time
Wuthering Heights

 

September 22, 2003

Let the discussion begin

Good evening!
I trust everyone has finished this month's selection of "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone" so I will get right to it.

Harry Potter has lived a miserable life since his parents' death. Left to survive with his horrible aunt and uncle, the Dursleys, and their spoiled son Dudley, Harry has been forced to live in a closet under the stairs. But as his eleventh birthday approaches, all this is about to change. A mysterious letter arrives by owl messanger, inviting him to attend Hogwarts School for Witchcraft and Wizardry. Harry is astonished to learn the truth about his parents — that they were wizards of the highest renown — and that he is destined to become one too. At Hogwarts, Harry finds friends and becomes an expert in Quidditch, an aerial sport played on broomsticks. But soon he becomes involved in a life-threatening struggle against the forces of darkness, and finds himself fighting for survival against those who would rather see him dead before he can come into his full powers.

Much of what is classified as high fantasy has as its central theme the classic struggle of good over evil. In this book, the suspense is also built by the fact that the evil of Voldemort and his followers is a tricky enemy to defeat, because much is hidden from plain sight. Harry and his friends, then, are left with a mystery to puzzle out before they can begin to understand and confront, let alone defeat, the enemy. Their task is made even more difficult as they cannot convince their superiors of the impending danger. The young heroes have to face their greatest challenges without any support from adults until the last few pages.

Did you like this book? What made this book exciting for you?



comments

I adore this book. It's so much fun. I think that it appeals to everyone's inner child. I mean...which one of us wouldn't love to find ourselves in the midst of an elite group of people that can perform magic? Not only that, but to find that you, also, had this amazing ability that you never even imagined could exist? All this plus high adventure and mischeif, too? I say this is fine fun and entertainment for the whole family!

Ah, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone...well, to be honest, I never wanted to read this book. When this novel? first came out, I didn't want to read it either. Book 5 came out and I still hadn't read one volume. I haven't seen the movie either. I actually wanted to see the movie. I didn't get a chance to. My point is, I am so sorry but, I haven't finished Harry Potter! Sigh, it's been quite a struggle for Harry Potter to keep my interest. I admit, some parts were interesting, suspenseful, and exciting, like Chapter 3. The whole letter thing was comical and exciting...but something about it. I'll admit, I am biased. I'm not into fantasy, unless it's close to Magical Realism like Garcia Marquez. The truth is that Harry Potter just didn't appeal to me. Although, I tried, I really tried getting into it.

The Harry Potter series is a longtime favorite of mine, but I resisted delving into it for years - until book three was out. It was actually my dad who got me to read the Harry Potter and the Sorceror's Stone, and it was out of respect for his judgment that I picked it up.

I've heard in many "Writers'" sour-grapey-sounding circles that the writing in HP is considered to be no great shakes, and that Ms. Rowling often writes as though she was getting paid by the word, but I think the proof, to wax cliché, is very much in the pudding. Harry has inspired a generation of kids to read in an era when American and British literacy figures were fast heading down the loo.

Commercial success aside, Rowling has improved the lives of millions of kids with her work. Knowledge of the Cabbage-Patch-like rushes for each new volume and the Christian Idiot Contingent's decrying of the series formed the background of the book for me when I picked it up, and yet still failed to prevent me from enjoying Rowling's show-don't-tell storytelling, accessible-though-British prose, and understated-though-rich characterization.

Is J.K. Rowling the next Shakespeare? Certainly not. Does she tell a damned fine story? In case it wasn't obvious by now, I definitely think so.

To me, the appeal of the book -- and the series, I suppose, although I'm only on book three -- comes from what Kate mentions in her opening post: the suspense.

The book isn't extraordinarily well-written, but then again, the writing isn't necessarily weak, either. Nor does the book really turn over everything to the reader's imagination; I'd argue that it does way too much telling for its own good.

But I think that largely contains its appeal: People get swept up in these books and finish them in a single sitting because they are so captivating. You just give yourself over to Jo and know that you're in capable hands. She crafts a beautiful and enrapturing, if often predictable, story that builds suspense almost flawlessly. Even when you know what's going to happen, you can't help but turn the page and keep reading.

I first saw the movie before reading the book. I was impressed by how true to the book the movie had been.

I've now read the book three times, and I've seen a lot more of the symbolism in it than when I first read it.

I've also read some other commentaries on the book, and I've linked back to the Harry Potter Prognostication weblog-- http://hpprogs.blogspot.com

You all may find that helpful. I did.

First and foremost, I think it’s awesome to be reading Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone in the midst of Banned Books Week. This series is #7 on the 100 Most Challenged Books (1990-200) and like many of the other titles on the list, I can’t really understand what the problem is. I think the Harry Potter series is one of the most imaginative, exciting books out there. The only problem I have is with the commercialism revolving around it: movies, dolls, pencils, bed sheets, video games, etc. A perfectly good story was mutated into a marketing bonanza that the public can’t escape. Then it seems that people are now divided: those that Love Harry Potter and those that vehemently Hate anything to do with it. Personally, I hate it when people choose not to read it strictly because it has become so popular. They really have no idea what a fun book they’re missing.

If you want the original experience, Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone, it might be worth ordering it from Amazon.co.uk (or, even the Canadian Amazon might carry the brit version). The story is essentially the same but the slang is so much more fun.

Did I like this book? Definately, when I read a book, I don't look for it to offer me the meaning of life, just some entertainment. This (and the whole series) did that, and more. It made me want to be a Hogwarts student!

What made it exciting for me was the fact that I was completely able to feel for these characters. That and the fact that my children could read these with me. It was so fun to discuss the book with them, and to ask them how cetain events made them feel, and what they would do. It's been in incredible experience for our family.

I quite enjoyed the Harry Potter series. Like many here, I didn't read it until long after it was started (book four had just come out in paperback)....I ended up reading the first four in a week and have read them all again since that time.

What really pleases me about this series is that it seems to be getting children back into reading, which is something to be treasured in a time where tv dominates so much time. JK Rowling may not be the best author out there, but she has managed to write books that are captivating for all ages.

I have to admit that, although the commercialism is sad, it has helped to spread the word about the book. And without the Radical Christian Right slamming this book, I may never have heard about it. Their arguments against it helped me make the decision to read the series in the first place.

I like many others LOVED Harry Potter. I think that even people that do not like fantasy can enjoy this book because as stated earlier by Kate, this is a classic good vs evil story. Granted it does have quite a few twists. If you are having a trouble reading this, I might suggest just sitting down and dont think about the idea of it being a "fantasy" .. think of it as just a book to enjoy. I find that many people are always so interested in finding "secret meanings" and trying to find the reasoning behind the writing style that they forget that this is a book to relax with and just plainly enjoy. I personally love the fact that this is such an easy read. I have read all of the book. I have also waited for the next one to come out. To tell you the truth I am quite a slow reader; however, I read book 5 in less than a week and that is with a full time job etc. The books apeal to everyone and I think that is why it has been so well received. I am rather happy that this was a book chosen for the month..especially banned book week/month.

I'm going to have to agree with (nearly) everyone else and say I have immensely enjoyed the Harry Potter series. I've only read books 1-3; book 4 is sitting somewhere in a TBR pile, of which I have many, and I'll get to book 5 at some point after it comes out in paperback. Although it is mostly entertainment and not Shakespeare as Rich mentioned, it definitely has its place in excellent contemporary literature. Personally, I feel that fiction should transport us into other worlds and realities and Harry Potter certainly does that.

Thanks to Amy for bringing up Banned Books Week. Rowling was the most challenged author last year for promoting witchcraft and wizardry to children. I used to participate in a professional book group at school and another teacher had mentioned the series as just the thing many kids needed to be inspired to read. The moderator, however, thought it was evil despite having never read it and actually wanted us to watch a video of some reverend explaining why it was corrupting our youth. I didn't watch the video, but instead began coming up with excuses for no longer being active in the group.

WEll, I love this book and the entire series. I don't think that Rowling is the next Shakespeare or some amazing writer, but I don't think that is the key to her sucess. The main thing about these books is the story. She tells a good story. She created this wonderful world that exists in our modern day society. The fact that there is this whole other culture that co-exists with the "normal" world is what makes it so fascinating. I love how she protrays the wizarding world.

I think the other key to her sucess is that she created characters that are genuinely likeable. We care about what happens to them. We have fallen in love with Harry, Ron and Hermione. Who doesn't want to go liv ein the Burrow with the Weasleys?

Hi, everyone! After reading bookblog for a while, I find myself unable to avoid commenting on harry potter. Sorry for introducing myself so bluntly, but this book really made me think, and I am interested in other peoples feelings about my opinion.

Since everyone has already posted about how much they love the book, here is my take on it. Harry potter books are the literary equivalent of james bond movies. Essentially the core of their popularity lies in their wish fulfillment, and rapid storytelling. After finishing the sorcerors stone, I found myself kind of mad at how obvious and pointless some of the wish fulfillment is. Why does harry have to be the youngest, and best, quiditch player in history his first year at hogwarts? Why does it figure that as soon as he discovers the magic world, all of his troubles go away? Doesn't the fact that the griffindors win the end of year cup at the very last minute remind you of the worst, most pandering movie endings? (think waterworld.)

Things are just too clearcut in Harry's world. I think that childrens books should be about people learning to grow, people dealing with adversity and discovering that there are no clear good/bad guys. Harry potter never grows as a character at all- all of his problems are found to be caused by the world around him. This is fiction truly from a childs point of view- where the protagonist never has to suffer the consequences of his actions, and rewards come from no effort. Not a good life lesson.

That being said, it is fun and easy to read, the same way most movies are fun to watch. But if thats all we cared about, we'd movie lovers, and not booklovers, wouldn't we?

 

Advertisements
 
 
Author:
Title:

Keyword:
Additional Features:
 First Edition
 Signed
 Dust Jacket
 Any Binding
 Hard Cover
 Soft Cover