Main
Search This Site

« back to More Evidence of Why I'm Not a Writer
» forward to To the Spoilers Go the Lawsuits

Discussion Archives
Bel Canto
blindness
A Box of Matches
Bridge of Birds

a canticle for leibowitz
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Chronicle of a Death Foretold
A Confederacy of Dunces
confessions of an ugly stepsister
Coraline
The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time

descent into hell
The Dew Breaker
The Diamond Age
Doctor Zhivago
don quixote

Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close

Fight Club
The Five People You Meet in Heaven
Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe

The Ghost Writer
good in bed

harry potter and the sorcerer's stone
A Home at the End of the World
House of Leaves

If on a Winter's Night a Traveler
invisible monsters

The Kite Runner

Life of Pi

memoirs of a geisha
Middlesex
Motherless Brooklyn
mysterious skin

Neverwhere
noir
Norwegian Wood

One for the Money

the poisonwood bible

revenge
Running with Scissors

The Secret Life of Bees
shopgirl
The Solitaire Mystery
The Stupidest Angel

Things Fall Apart
Thumbsucker
The Time Traveler's Wife
Troll

Veronika Decides to Die

The Wasp Factory
Watch Your Mouth
What is the What
A Wrinkle in Time
Wuthering Heights

 

July 20, 2007

Regarding The Purpose of a Novel

POD Critic is wise...

Now I know I’ve touched on this particular subject in previous posts, but I have to ask the question again, “What is the purpose of a novel?” This is not necessarily related to another question, “Why have you decided to write a novel?” The second question can have various answers, many, if not all of them involving some personal agenda on the part of the writer or writers in question. But the answer to the first question, and in all truth, there really is only one answer (which I’ve supplied in this particular post already) is to entertain. Keeping this in mind, that a novel’s main—and in most cases nowadays—sole purpose, is to entertain, a writer should be able to approach a book with this decidedly singular agenda, abutting it and supplementing it with experimentation, lofty artistic objectives, or other personal goals, so long as the primary agenda remains in full frontal view.


TrackBacks
 
http://www.bookblog.net/mt/mt-tb.cgi/519
 
comments

I certainly agree that the the novel's main purpose is to entertain. Unfortunately, I think many authors forget this important point and get caught up in all of the other things that can help make a novel great but shouldn't be the central focus. Of course, sometimes the author goes completely the other way only thinking about being entertaining and you get something like The Da Vinci Code. In which, frankly, the prose sucks.

I disagree. I mean, I agree that one purpose of a novel is to entertain; however, the novel (and other genres) should have one intrinsic, sine qua non, unique purpose that sets it apart from other genres. Nonfiction, particularly biographies, can be written with an entertainment purpose. I believe purpose that identifies the novel as a novel is to create a world of what could be.

Yes, but what's the point in creating "a world of what could be" if it isn't entertaining to readers?

But readers (and writers) have different interests and thus different ideas about what is entertaining. It's an objective yardstick, and therefore hardly of use to determine whether or not something as broad and wide as fiction meets its purpose.

I largely agree with your point. There are degrees though to which "to entertain" can apply (and I won't get into the semantics of what "entertainment" consists of - let's assume it's not necessarily "having fun!" which seems a little constrictive).

I would answer the first question with "to tell a story which entertains". Novelists are storytellers first and foremost. Naturally, it goes hand-in-hand with having something to say which will keep our attention.

Interestingly, this could probably be articulated in a graph, where X is the story and Y is...ok, that's going too far.

I'm going to base my take on the purpose of a novel in relation to "Wearing the Spider" by Susan Schaab, my latest read. Author's write novel's to share their experiences and knowledge with the rest of the world in hopes that people will understand what goes on in their mind which may give an author a sense of universal understanding. Susan Schaab combines her experiences as a woman in the business world, the world of technology, the corporate legal world and the romantic ideology of a female and presents it in a book format. When a combination like this works it produces an excellent novel that will bring satisfaction to a reader and an author.

I still have to ask What is the purpose of a novel that cannot be meet by any other genre?

Matt, sure, there are degrees to entertainment since it is a subjective thing. But I again have to ask, what's the point of telling a (fiction) story if it isn't entertaining? I think the entertainment component is first and foremost, with the rest of the purposes of a novel trailing behind.

Rachel, thanks for the spam.

Elizabeth, I don't really think a novel has to have a purpose unique unto itself. Before TV, books were entertainment. Before books, people told stories. Although degree of entertainment is subjective based on the tastes of each reader, novelists should begin writing with entertainment as the primary goal.

How can the entertainment component precede the story itself? It's like writing a punch-line and then trying come up with the joke that preceded it.

As regards "entertainment", if it can apply equally to such disparate works as those of Margaret Lawrence, Albert Camus, and Dean R. Koontz (seeing as they are/were all successful authors with a faithful fanbase), then the meaning of "entertainment" becomes a little vague. Not to be semantic, but I would put a greater value on what is "compelling" rather than what is "entertainment".

We might be engaging in a chicken & egg debate here, but it think it comes down to a word: purpose. Before a novel is even conceived, the drive to come up with a story has to be entertaining others.

Entertainment is subjective, but don't you think being compelled by a story is one form of entertainment? I read some stories and become sad, others make me laugh, others make me angry, etc. When I'm reading a novel, though, I'm diverting myself from the things I have to do (like working or cleaning) by entertaining myself.

I know I'm like a dog with a bone, continuing to gnaw at this one point, but the question wasn't what is the purpose of a BOOK or the purpose of WRITING, but rather the specific instance of a NOVEL. Furthermore, the author would find the "possible world" entertaining, or the idea of exploring this other possibility entertaining, else, I agree, what would be the point of writing his story? Marydell, I also agree with you that stories preceded novels; however, I think their purpose was to explain/understand this world. I think this point is most clearly proved when we consider he number of creation stories/stories that explain nature.

Perhaps we're never going to be able to agree on this. Novels for me are entertainment, plain and simple, and novelists are entertainers who employ writing as their medium. The best novelists have raised composition of prose and plot to the level of art, but I still pick up that artful book as a diversion.

I don't know much about anthropology, yet I do agree that stories arose from a desire to explain and understand the world. However, I suspect that the very first nature/creation story ever told by ancient man was supposed to be non-fiction. It just seems more natural to me that non-fiction, no matter how mythological the stories might seem to us today, came first. Fiction, I can easily believe, could have developed from there as a form of entertainment.

post a comment














Comments on this site are moderated. If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by BookBlog before your comment will appear. Thanks for waiting.



 

Advertisements
 
 
Author:
Title:

Keyword:
Additional Features:
 First Edition
 Signed
 Dust Jacket
 Any Binding
 Hard Cover
 Soft Cover